Fantasy 'Potter'

It’s been four days since I finished Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. Four long days of mild depression, plus the occasional fit of weeping and clothes-renting. Not to be too biblical about it, but I am wearing sackcloth right now.

A friend of mine has embraced the latest release in Jasper Fforde’s Thursday Next series, and I, too, am forced to select a coping mechanism.

I began my quest for post-Potter serenity by watching a yet-unseen-by-me succession of Woody Allen movies. I don’t know why I thought that was a good idea — as though four-eyed characters are interchangeable or something. When the sheer volume of anxious ticks set to jazz music became grating, I scrubbed my kitchen squeaky (next stop, bathroom), but alas, no sponge or disinfectant could mend my broken heart. (Though I daresay the ammonia didn’t hurt.)

Until Netflix sends my Weeds, Season 2 discs, and until my younger sister finishes the damn book so we can have a proper wake for dearly departed Fred Weasley, I’ve finally accepted that I can’t yet turn my gaze from Harry. And with that knowledge, I have chosen to fantasy-cast the two remaining movies; because if there’s one thing I love as much as a good book, it’s pretending I have the decision-making clout of a powerful Hollywood executive.


Horace Slughorn: Brian Cox

Two individuals from this office proffered Bob Hoskins for Slughorn, the rotund potions master of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, but I still favor Brian Cox. His dance card’s rather full for the next few years, but surely he can fit one giant spider burial into his schedule, with a possible post-graveside-service rendition of “Odo the Hero.” (Music from the motion picture, track 1: “Odo the Hero,” lyrics: J.K. Rowling; vocals: Brian Cox, Robbie Coltrane; musical arrangement: Coldplay.)

Rufus Scrimgeour: Hugh Laurie

Rowling gives Half-Blood Prince’s replacement Minister of Magic Rufus Scrimgeour a worn, elderly lion-like visage. I’ve always imagined him as a scruffy Robert Redford. But that won’t do — ol’ Sundance is America. It’s come down to two — Jeremy Irons and Hugh Laurie, and (Pikachu!) I choose Hugh! He’s got the limp down pat — just imagine it was caused by a dark wizard and not an aneurysm. Plus, he can chill with old friend Emma Thompson on the set.

Aberforth Dumbledore: Michael Caine

One minute this Deathly Hallows character is fiddle-di-deeing with goats, the next he’s sharing the tragic, chilling story of his and Dumbledore’s deceased sister with Harry & Co. There’s just one person to play this hot-cold part (though he would have made a damn fine Albus, too): the Alfie and the O’Malley, Michael Caine.

Marvolo Gaunt: Bill Nighy

Strange, how the actors we most endear — the funniest, the goofiest — can contort themselves into the cruelest characters when they want to. Consider the cold-hearted, blue-blooded Bill Nighy of The Constant Gardener, or the vicious and proud tentacle-faced Nighy of the Pirates series. Finally, recall how damn scary Bill (and some makeup artists) made himself appear as he transformed into a zombie in Shaun of the Dead. Combine all three, and I think we’ve got a suitable, brutally mean grandpappy for Voldemort on our hands.

Hepzibah Smith: Judi Dench

Judi Dench has never achieved the expansive body mass of Hepzibah Smith, the aged bourgeois woman-child of Half-Blood, but Imelda Staunton isn’t the squat toad Rowling describes Dolores Umbridge as in book five, either, and she got cast. So I vote for the great Dame Dench to sink her scenery-chewing teeth into this small but engaging role (she’s in possession of a horcrux, for Pete’s sake, you can’t cut her!). Picture the still girlishly charming actress seated on a giant pink poof, lording over a house-elf named Hokey and making passes at a young Voldemort. Priceless.

Xenophilius Lovegood: Jim Broadbent

Who else would have raised his daughter to believe in Nargles and Crumple-Horned Snorkacks? This book-seven character has the critical role of explaining the novel’s titular elements, the Deathly Hallows, to our band on the run — just before he betrays them to the Death Eaters. He’s not a Judas, he just wants his daughter back … which is why Jim, who’s always exuded a paternal aura (“You’re dying, Satine.” Sob!), is the ideal Quibbler editor and Luna-spawner.

Gellert Grindelwald: Peter O’Toole

Sure, this pre-Voldemort dark wizard, long since defeated by Dumbledore, only shows up for about a page in Deathly Hallows (when V-dawg soars up to his prison-tower for the purpose of acquiring Grindy’s Wand of Destiny — the world’s most powerful magic stick), but he’s exactly the skeletal being I envisioned declaring “I welcome death” to the heir of Slytherin. And wouldn’t it be great if he received that we-owe-you-one Oscar for his 60-second performance? 

Scroll to read more Movie Reviews & News articles
Join the San Antonio Current Press Club

Local journalism is information. Information is power. And we believe everyone deserves access to accurate independent coverage of their community and state.
Help us keep this coverage going with a one-time donation or an ongoing membership pledge.


Join SA Current Newsletters

Subscribe now to get the latest news delivered right to your inbox.