No News is Bad News. Join the SA Current Press Club.

Reproductive outlook? 

Priests For Life founder Father Frank Pavone speaks at the Tennessee Right to Life Headquarters.
The desert breeds obsession; look to the Middle East-spawned religions of Judaism, Christianity, and Islam for proof of that. These kindred monotheisms spring from fanatics wrestling with avenging angels, inner demons, and a smiting God under a hammering sun, and while these legends make for engaging sermons, they have little to do with the reality average people face every day. It may be why the anti-choice group Priests For Life has planted itself in Amarillo, Texas, where the Great Plains crumble into the sands of the American Southwest. Isolated from civilization and deep in the blood-red heart of Republican Texas, these modern-day Torquemadas, led by Father Frank Pavone, are facing the recent defeat of policies that oppose reproductive freedom.

The facts aren’t encouraging for fundamentalists on either side of the Reformation: California and Oregon defeated a measure that would have required parents of women under 18 to be notified before an abortion was performed; in South Dakota, arguably one of the country’s most conservative states, 56 percent of voters killed a proposed law to ban all abortions except in cases where it was absolutely necessary to save a woman’s life — which, for an anti-choice advocate, is never as valuable as that of the unborn; and Missouri passed a constitutional amendment, vigorously opposed by evangelical Christians as well as the Roman Catholic Archdiocese of St. Louis, protecting stem-cell research.

Pavone and his handful of followers appear to have violated regulations for tax-exempt nonprofits, effectively crossing “the line by publishing a Voter’s Guide which clearly delineated who they thought people should vote for, based on keywords and criteria (such as ‘pro-life’),” according to Frances Kissling, president of Catholics For A Free Choice. Pavone’s rationale, “government is subservient to God and that man-made laws are only legitimate when they adhere to God’s law,” defies the Constitution and makes the Catholic Church guilty by association. The group’s move more than a year ago to Amarillo from Staten Island may in fact be a banishment, considering the church promotes progressive policies overall if sex is removed from the equation. Kissling added that the Catholic Church isn’t “monolithic. Most bishops, including Cardinal Egan in New York, understand that Pavone crosses the line, and try to keep a distance. A few radicals, like `Bishop` Yanta `of the Diocese of Amarillo`, however, want to push these issues regardless of the law and provide cover for Pavone.”

The electoral shift to the left wasn’t across the board, and Texas voters, as a rule, stayed conservative, but pro-choice proponents did see some improvements — six new state representatives and a new state senator support the right to choose. Yvonne Gutierrez, director of communications and public affairs of the Planned Parenthood Trust of San Antonio and South Central Texas, is optimistic that local women will see improvements in reproductive rights. Despite the political leanings of Texas as a whole, Gutierrez feels that San Antonio isn’t as “ideologically conservative as everyone thinks,” and that groups like Priests For Life don’t grasp the realities women face. Because despite the conversion of a free service Southside Planned Parenthood to a full-fee clinic and a diversion of $10 million in funding to Federally Qualified Health Centers for family planning care, San Antonio’s Planned Parenthood patient donations reached $150,000 last year. Proving that the value of Planned Parenthood doesn’t go unnoticed, especially by those utilizing their services (the clinic saw approximately 30,000 patients last year; only 1,400 were for abortion procedures).

Religious conservatives won’t grasp how humans actually deal with sexuality and reproduction anytime soon. The ongoing U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops approved on November 14 a document encouraging married couples to use “natural” contraception based on a woman’s menstrual cycle. As any woman (or any man who’s ever lived with a woman) could tell you, that gamble is more likely to pay off with another mouth to feed than not. Unless they’re willing to do more than pray for the results of that gamble, these celibate, cloistered men of conviction could best serve by sitting in the sun and tending to their personal, heat-induced mirages.

"The original article incorrectly cited five new state representatives support the right to choose; that $10 million in family care dollars were diverted to religious groups; that the Southside Planned Parenthood clinic was closed; and that 10,000 abortion procedures had been performed by San Antonio's Planned Parenthood last year. The corrections have been made above."

San Antonio Current works for you, and your support is essential.

Our small but mighty local team works tirelessly to bring you high-quality, uncensored news and cultural coverage of San Antonio and beyond.

Unlike many newspapers, ours is free – and we'd like to keep it that way, because we believe, now more than ever, everyone deserves access to accurate, independent coverage of their community.

Whether it's a one-time acknowledgement of this article or an ongoing pledge, your support helps keep San Antonio's true free press free.

Read the Digital Print Issue

September 23, 2020

View more issues


Never miss a beat

Sign Up Now

Subscribe now to get the latest news delivered right to your inbox.


© 2020 San Antonio Current

Website powered by Foundation