Where to Find Pumpkin Pie in San Antonio

By San Antonio Current Staff

It's no secret that everyone loves pumpkin pie. And with a certain local barbecue chain bringing it back to its menu for the season, we decided to round up some places where you can score the fall dessert – just in case you were serious about that boycott.

Scroll down to view images

Join the San Antonio Current Press Club

At a time when local-based reporting is critical, support from our readers is essential to our future. Join the San Antonio Current Press Club for as little as $5 a month

Del’s Desserts
delsdesserts.com
Baked to order and made from scratch, this local, at-home baker is all about sweet goodness. Made with a butter crust, this pumpkin pie is reason enough to support local.
Photo via Instagram / delsdesserts

Annie’s Petite Treats
anniespetitetreats.com
Make sure you get your fix of pumpkin pie from Annie’s Petite Treats while you still can. The local baker will have the pie available to order throughout October and November.
Photo via Instagram / anniespetitetreats

Kneaders Bakery & Café
Multiple locations, kneaders.com
This joint bakery-cafe will bring you the good stuff this holiday season. In addition to a pumpkin chocolate chip cookie, pumpkin cheesecake and pumpkin chocolate chip chip petite cake (!), Nana’s Pumpkin Pie is also available for your pumpkin pleasure.
Photo via Instagram / kneaders

Mr. & Mrs. G's Homecooking
2222 S WW White Road, (210) 359-0002
Homecooking, thankfully, includes some freshly baked pies made with love. Swing by this East Side institution for some scrumptious sweet potato pie.
Photo via Instagram / mikaziljanessa

H-E-B
Multiple locations, heb.com
Whether you need a pie to take to your holiday party or just feel like stuffing your face and need a quick fix, you can trust the bakery at your local H-E-B to come through. It’s a tried-and-true favorite.
Photo via Instagram / heb

Bakery Lorraine
Multiple locations, bakerylorraine.com
Of course local powerhouse Bakery Lorraine will be serving up this seasonal staple. Beginning in late October you’ll find pumpkin pie on display and available for purchase at any of Bakery Lorraine’s Alamo City locations.
Photo via Instagram / bakery_lorraine

Tootie Pie
129 Industrial Dr, Boerne, (210) 737-6600, tootiepieco.com
If you’re dedicated to finding the best pies in the area, you won’t mind making the drive to Boerne for Tootie Pie. The pumpkin pie, handcrafted into creation, is truly worth every penny.
Photo via Instagram / tootiepieco

Mrs. Kitchen Soul Food Restaurant and Bakery
2242 E Commerce St, (210) 549-4392, mrskitchensa.com
Of course Mrs. Kitchen comes through with sinfully delicious pies. Freshly made in a variety of flavors, the sweet potato pie will change your world.
Photo via Instagram / amejiajr8

Fontaine’s Southern Diner & Bar
906 E Elmira St, (210) 236-9013, fontainesdiner.com
Still new to SA’s food scene, Fontaine’s is proving itself to be a dependable spot for lots of antojos. Among the treats you’ll find here is pumpkin pie, which will be available as of mid-October. Be sure to swing by and grab a slice or two!
Photo courtesy of Fontaine’s

Bird Bakery
5912 Broadway St, (210) 804-2473, birdbakery.com
Stop by this Alamo Heights bakery and you’ll be able score lots of cutely decorated treats that are just as sweet as they look. Within the menu you’ll be able to choose from a limited selection of pies, including a good ol’ pumpkin pie or even a pumpkin cheesecake.
Photo via Instagram / stargazer7714