San Antonio residents protest against the ICE detainment of a Alamo Heights family earlier this year. Credit: Michael Karlis

A poll conducted ahead of the midterm elections by the American Civil Liberties Union of Texas shows widespread opposition to a U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) proposal to open a new detention center in San Antonio.

More than half of registered Texas voters expressed concerns about the facility, from the treatment of detainees to its cost to taxpayers.

According to the ACLU, 48% of respondents said they oppose the East Side ICE detention center, compared to just 35% who support it.

Additionally, 65% of respondents are concerned about the $83 million cost to taxpayers. ICE paid $66 million to purchase the building in January and signed a $17.3 million contract with GardaWorld Federal Services to renovate the facility.

The ACLU also reports that 59% of respondents are concerned about the treatment of detainees, while 58% expressed concerns about the living and sanitary conditions they could face.

The poll also found that 58% of respondents are concerned that ICE could skip normal permit and regulatory processes to get approval.

In October, the City of San Antonio sued to pause the 640,000-square-foot facility, arguing the Department of Homeland Security sidestepped requirements under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), including a mandatory environmental review.

Last week, Mayor Gina Ortiz Jones said the legal action had succeeded in pausing at least some construction on the facility while federal officials conduct the required environmental review.

Nonetheless, 53% of the ACLU’s survey respondents expressed concern that San Antonio’s elected officials haven’t done enough to oppose the facility.

For her part, Jones has been vocal about her goal of shutting down the facility for good.

“Look, pushing back has had the effect that we want up until now,” Jones told TPR earlier this month. “Obviously, the ultimate effect is no ICE detention facility in San Antonio.”


Texas politics is a mess. We make it a readable mess.


Stephanie Koithan is the Digital Content Editor of the San Antonio Current. In her role, she writes about politics, music, art, culture and food. Send her a tip at skoithan@sacurrent.com.