Gov. Greg Abbott touts Texas’ open doors for data center development at media event with Google officials last November. Credit: Courtesy Photo / Gov. Greg Abbott

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott early this month issued a moratorium on data center development in the state until regulating authorities can conduct an audit of the sites seeking to connect to the power grid.

On the surface, the move appears to get the Republican governor ahead of a growing backlash against the power- and water-hogging computing facilities. 

However, critics say the pause is largely empty rhetoric thanks to built-in loopholes. And without legislation to back it up, activists warn Abbott’s tough talk is “toothless.”

In a public rebuke, watchdog group Public Citizen calls Abbott’s action a “faux pause.” As part of its scathing critique, the nonprofit added that the moratorium is “so vague that it should be considered meaningless.”

“It’s another Band-Aid,” said Adrian Shelley, Public Citizen’s Texas director. “The state has so many data centers already operating or on their way because Abbott’s approach is to roll out the welcome mat to corporate interests first and figure out how to protect the interests of working Texans later, if at all. If the governor is honest about addressing data centers, he should immediately call a special session of the Texas Legislature to demand a real moratorium. Regulating by press release just isn’t going to cut it.”

The Aug. 3 moratorium has proved to be a departure from Abbott’s earlier embrace of the deep-pocketed data center industry. As recently as last November, he crowed that Texas would become the “epicenter of AI development.” 

However, Abbott is now in the midst of a heated election season as bipartisan opposition to the Texas AI boom grows. He’s polling neck-and-neck with State Rep. Gina Hinojosa, his Democratic challenger, for a seat he’s held for 11 years.

As such, Abbott has started talking tough on data centers, including a June 10 directive introducing guardrails for industry development in the state. Those include minimizing the impact on local residents’ electricity bills, requiring that data centers pay for their own electricity infrastructure and demanding that they use water-efficient technologies such as closed-loop cooling systems.

In his subsequent Aug. 3 letter, Abbott called for a pause on connecting data centers to the grid until the Electric Reliability Council of Texas (ERCOT) and the Public Utility Commission of Texas (PUCT) — the state’s energy regulators — can conduct an audit. 

However, little is known about the moratorium, including how many data centers will be audited and how the information gathered in the audit will be used by regulators and legislators. 

A week after Abbott’s announcement, ERCOT clarified that it expects the audit to last “several months,” adding that it will begin shortly after Aug. 20.

Since Abbott’s Aug. 3 pronouncement, at least 43 companies — including hyperscalers such as Meta, OpenAI, Microsoft and Amazon Web Services — have publicly expressed support for Abbott’s audit. Hardly a sign the governor is putting the thumbscrews to the industry. 

“We share your commitment to ensuring data centers are true partners in every Texas community where we operate — protecting residential ratepayers, strengthening grid reliability and promoting responsible water stewardship,” the Data Center Coalition, a trade association representing many of the world’s largest tech companies, told the governor in a recent letter, as reported by the Texas Tribune.

In turn, Abbott has been sure to publicize each cooperative statement from industry leaders as proof that his bold words are scaring them straight. Since the guardrails and moratorium were announced, Abbott’s press office has released 11 separate press releases announcing that more data center companies have “committed to comply with his data center standards.” 

“What Governor Abbott is doing is working,” wrote Andrew Mahaleris, Abbott’s press secretary, as reported by the Texas Tribune. “Data centers across the state have announced their full compliance with those standards, which provide guardrails that protect our communities.”

‘Performative on everybody’s part

Not everyone is convinced by the flurry of self-congratulatory rhetoric — neither by Abbott nor the industry he’s purportedly regulating.

“It’s all very performative, it’s performative on everybody’s part,” Texas Politics Project Director Jim Henson told the Texas Tribune of the spectacle.

Critics said the industry’s glowing endorsement is because Abbott’s call for a pause leaves strategically advantageous wiggle room for data center developers.

“When the companies being regulated are cheering for the rules, you know the rules were written for them, not for Texans,” Hinojosa said in a statement emailed to the Current.

Additionally, nothing Abbott has done so far is likely to slow down major projects already in the works, according to observers.

ERCOT is taking steps to ensure that energization dates for the most advanced projects will not be “unnecessarily delayed,” according to a tweet by Matthew Sigel, head of digital assets research for VanEck, a global asset management firm specializing in energy and emerging markets. 

Multiple major data-center projects are still expected to proceed as scheduled with their early 2027 completion dates, including a $50 billion Nvidia campus called Beacon Point being built near Corpus Christi.

In other words, Abbott’s moratorium — like much of President Donald Trump’s endless issuance of executive orders — is toothless without legislation to back it up, critics argue.

Public Citizen’s Shelley argues that the view from the ground tells another story about the governor’s handling of the data center boom.

“The governor’s announcement is not a real pause,” Shelley said. “Permits are still being issued. Land is still being cleared. The governor should ask residents in communities across Texas if they see the data center development next to their home being ‘paused.’”

On the phone with the Current, Shelley added that the “only tangible pause” that has happened since Abbott’s decree is ERCOT’s announcement that it has put a hold on its Batch Zero process — or its system of processing an unprecedented number of connection requests.

“Texas is experiencing an energy transformation unlike anything we have seen before,” ERCOT President and CEO Pablo Vegas said about the Batch Zero process when the PUCT approved it in June as a rapid-response solution to the unheard-of demand. 

ERCOT faces a record-breaking 2,000 projects in its interconnection queue, agency officials said, and about 90% of them are data centers. Many of these are large-load requests, representing a total demand of 438,000 megawatts. That’s more than four times the demand of the entire state of Texas on July 22, 2026, which holds the all-time record energy demand for a single day at 91,089 MW.

However, the Aug. 3 pause on Batch Zero doesn’t apply to all data centers — only projects that have a demand of 75 MW or more. 

As a result, some industry experts are touting the idea of data centers keeping their demand below the 75 MW threshold as the “fastest path to power.” 

Indeed, using techniques such as battery energy storage, some under-75 MW projects may even be accelerated, according to Quincy Lee, founder and CEO of Electric Era. On its website, the energy infrastructure company promises to deliver power “above the local grid limit” to “save years of time” and work around “20th century energy infrastructure” that the business claims is holding back the burgeoning industry. 

Electric Era also touts its modular power skids — or pre-assembled, self-contained electrical systems designed to fit standard flatbed semi-trailers — which can be taken online from a parking lot. Advertised as an overnight solution to respond to “rapidly evolving requirements,” the skids are designed to quickly scale power capacity at a later date.

Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) and modular, scalable power skids aren’t the only workaround being exploited during the so-called “pause” on data centers, according to experts. Some data centers are already opting to go “off-grid” by building their own fossil-fuel-burning power plants. 

Amazon plans to build a massive West Texas data center that critics say will be one of the nation’s biggest sources of air pollution. Credit: Wikimedia Commons / Tony Webster

Public Citizen estimates that at least 40 Texas data centers are currently powered by their own gas-burning plants. Industry experts call this approach “getting behind the meter.”

Vantage, which uses a co-located gas power plant and backup diesel generators to power its two San Antonio data centers, is one such example. The new Amazon data center campus that just broke ground in the West Texas town of Fort Stockton is another — and environmentalists warn it could be poised to become the nation’s worst emitter of air pollution.

Right now, data centers and their off-grid power sources are treated as separate entities, enabling the computing facilities to apply for small-scale air polluter permits called Minor NSRs. Those are the same pre-construction air permits reserved for small businesses such as laundromats. 

Such minor NSRs generate less pollution than the Environmental Protection Agency’s threshold — typically 100-250 tons of pollution per year — in order to be considered a “major source” of pollution. 

Turning up the pressure

Public Citizen’s Shelley said he’s lobbying at the Texas Capitol for legislation treating data centers and their off-grid power sources as related entities. With that loophole eliminated, the true pollution and resource demands associated with powering such a facility would no longer be obscured. 

After all, Houston electric utility company VoltaGrid’s San Antonio gas-driven power plant wouldn’t exist without the need to power Vantage’s two West Side data centers, located on Omicron Drive and Rogers Road. 

Meanwhile, lawmakers on both sides of the aisle are expressing interest in crafting legislation around data centers to address the growing concerns of their constituents, Shelley said. 

“I am meeting with legislative staff almost every day at this point, and most of them are interested in legislating on this,” Shelley said. “Many of them are already drafting bills. They are ready to get working on this right now because they’re hearing about it from their constituents almost every day.”

To be sure, politicians in Abbott’s own party are increasingly voicing their displeasure with the data center boom, among them controversial San Antonio-area congressional candidate Brandon “AK Guy” Herrera, House Speaker Dustin Burrows and Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick.

Texas Agriculture Commissioner Sid Miller, a Republican who lost his primary after Abbott endorsed his GOP rival Nate Sheets, called the governor’s about-face on data centers “political theater” and a “dog-and-pony show.” Miller even joined with the progressive Democratic candidate for Texas Agriculture Commissioner — a goat farmer named Clayton Tucker — in calling for a special session on the boom.

At least 82 data centers, or nearly 60% of those that are either planned or under construction, are in state House districts that voted for Trump in 2024 and have a Republican state representative, according to a recent Texas Tribune analysis.

In such unincorporated rural areas, county governments have little power to block such development — something some Republican state reps are hoping to change.

Further bolstering widespread skepticism about Abbott’s intentions, the governor has accepted $2.5 million in campaign contributions over the past few months alone from donors who benefit from the Texas AI boom. A new campaign ad by Hinojosa claims that Abbott’s total contributions from the AI industry over the years top $20 million.

AI-aligned super PACs spent more than $4 million on Texas Republicans this primary cycle overall, according to the Tech Oversight Project, a Washington, D.C.-based nonprofit that supports regulations on data centers.

And while Abbott talks tough, Shelley said the governor alone holds the key to actually getting something done on data centers.

That is, if that’s what Abbott truly wants.

“Greg Abbott is the only person in Texas who could call a special session on this,” Shelley said. “He could do it today, he could do it tomorrow. And as long as we get press releases and representations about what should be happening, it’s just talk at this point, as far as we’re concerned.”


30,000 San Antonians can’t be wrong. Sign up today for San Antonio Current newsletters.

Stephanie Koithan is the Digital Content Editor of the San Antonio Current. In her role, she writes about politics, music, art, culture and food. Send her a tip at skoithan@sacurrent.com.