Winner: Cullum’s Attagirl
726 E. Mistletoe Ave.
(210) 437-4263
cullumsattagirl.com
The Cullum’s Attagirl name may not adorn the sign of this St. Mary’s Strip fave, but take its win in this category as your sign to pay it another visit. Locals and visitors alike love Attagirl for its fresh, hip take on Southern cuisine, and its crisp, melt-in-your-mouth fried yardbird is definitely a star attraction. Don’t sleep on the fries, sandos and impressive craft beer selection either. Word of warning: if you decide to have a romantic date enjoying some of Attagirl’s chicken under the mood lighting of the outdoor patio, wipe the chicken grease off your mouth before you make out.
2. Bill Miller’s
Multiple locations
billmillerbbq.com
3. Southerleigh Fine Food And Brewery
136 E. Grayson St., Suite 120
(210) 455-5701
southerleighatpearl.com
This article appears in Jul 23 – Aug 6, 2025.