San Antonio-based USAA serves military members, veterans and their families. Credit: Sanford Nowlin

San Antonio-based insurance and financial services giant USAA faces a legal fight before the California Supreme Court over allegations that it charged enlisted military personnel higher auto insurance rates than officers.

The class action lawsuit, originally filed in San Diego, alleges that USAA violated California insurance laws by charging enlisted service members more for coverage despite their qualifying driving records, the Times of San Diego reports.

Consumer Watchdog, an advocacy group representing the plaintiffs, estimates that around 200,000 enlisted USAA policyholders were overcharged, according to the news outlet. The company, one of San Antonio’s largest employers, serves military personnel, veterans and their family members.

Proposition 103, a California ballot measure approved in 1988, is central to the suit. That regulation requires insurance companies to offer qualifying good drivers their lowest available rates, regardless of military rank.

A federal judge in San Diego previously sided with USAA, ruling that subsequent legislation exempted insurers serving exclusively military personnel from the measure’s requirements, the Times of San Diego reports.

However, the plaintiffs appealed to the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which referred the case to California’s highest court because of conflicting interpretations of state insurance law.

The case could have implications extending beyond USAA and military policyholders, according to the article. Consumer Watchdog argues that the ruling could affect millions of Californians purchasing auto, home and business insurance.

Attorney Cyrus Mehri, who represents the plaintiffs, argues that legislation designed to protect military insurance programs shouldn’t allow companies to charge enlisted personnel more.

“USAA should not be allowed to evade that protection by sorting military families into different corporate affiliates based on pay level,” Mehri told the Times of San Diego.

In a statement to the Current, USAA officials defended the company’s record of providing value to military personnel.

“The allegations in this suit have no merit, which is why it was dismissed at the trial court,” public relations director Roger Wildermuth said. “We will continue to defend against this suit.”


30,000 San Antonians can’t be wrong. Sign up today for San Antonio Current newsletters.

Sanford Nowlin is editor-in-chief of the San Antonio Current. He holds degrees from Trinity University and the University of Texas at San Antonio, and his work has been featured in Salon, Alternet, Creative...